Fossil hunting guidelines

Kindly provided to Discovering Fossils by Dan Quinsey © 2008
Mary Anning was born on May 21, 1799 in the town of Lyme Regis, a
small seaport on the English Channel in the southwest corner of the
county of Dorset. Her parents, Richard and Molly, had at least 10
children but only Mary and her older brother Joseph survived
childhood. In those days nearly half the children under the age of
five died, mostly from smallpox or measles.
Mary was named both
after her mother Molly, whose given name was Mary, and an older
sister who was killed at the age of four in a house fire during
Christmas 1798.
Famine struck soon after Mary's birth. England and
France were locked in a war, and French war ships blocked the coast
of England, which slowed imports and drove up the cost of food. Poor
and working-class people now spent almost half their income on bread
alone. Determined to end price gouging and mass starvation, a mob
gathered In Lyme in March of 1800. Led by Richard Anning, they
attacked several estates and a mill. The government put down the
riot and those who were put on trial were soon released, as no one
in Lyme would testify against them.
On August 19, 1800, the Anning's nurse, Mrs Haskins, took Mary, who was weak and sickly, to
a horse show in hopes that the fresh air might help her. Heavy rain
interrupted the show, and Mrs Haskins and Mary took shelter under
an elm tree along with two teenage girls. When lightning struck the
elm, everyone was killed except Mary.
Mary's childhood was filled
with calamities. Richard Anning's best friend John Cruikshanks was
so discouraged by money problems, he killed himself by leaping from
Gun Cliff, which was right in front of the Anning home. The
following year, the 'Great Fire of Lyme' consumed Crossman's bakery,
a cloth factory, and forty-two homes. The Anning's home was spared.
About 1,450 people lived in Lyme. Mary's home was located on top
of a huge stone sea wall called Gun Cliff after the large cannons
that lined it. Her window faced the sea. Below, a walkway called the
Marine Parade spanned the River Lym down to the Cobb. The Cobb,
which means 'rounded island' in the local dialect, was a
600-foot-long stone curved jetty that created one of the oldest
artificial harbours in England.
Lyme Regis was one of the best
places in the world to find curiosities. Since the sixteenth
century, people had called anything dug out of the earth 'fossils',
from the Latin word for 'dug up' from the ground.
Richard Anning
struggled as a cabinetmaker and supplemented his income by selling
curiosities he found on the beach. He took Mary to the beach on many
occasions looking for loose spiral-shaped stones called snake
stones or Ammon's Horns. Some of the Anning's neighbours believed
these stones had magical healing powers. Richard used part of his
cabinet shop to clean and display these curiosities.
Richard
taught Mary how to increase the value of a fossil by cleaning it
with a needle and a tiny brush. He also taught her how to polish
fossils and display them in fine wooden boxes.
The Anning's were
Dissenters, those who disagreed with the Anglican Church or the
Church of England. Mary started attending the Dissenters Sunday
school in Lyme sometime near her eighth birthday. There, she learned
to read and write. Joseph gave her a bound volume of the Dissenters
theological magazine and Review. Mary kept this book her entire
life. One essay insisted God created the universe in six days, while
another urged Dissenters to study geology. Many people believed
studying the earth's layers could help prove the Biblical account of
Creation.
In 1807, Richard Anning was seriously injured one
evening when he tumbled over a cliff at Black Ven and fell over 100
feet. He never fully recovered and died on November 5, 1810. Richard
owed more than 120 pounds, more than he made in a year. Without his
income, the Anning family went on parish relief - three shillings a
week - barely enough to prevent starvation.
Molly was depressed
by her husband's death and paid little attention to Mary. Ignored by
her grieving mother, Mary started wandering the shores on her own.
She showed a lady an Ammon's horn she had found. The woman liked it
and bought it. Mary was convinced she could earn money selling
fossils.
Molly had sometimes complained Richard's fossil hunting
was a waste of time, but Mary's sales would soon change her mind.
In 1811, Mary's brother Joseph found an odd looking fossil embedded
in rock that had fallen on the shore. It was four feet long and
looked like a lizard's skull. Mary was determined to find the rest
of the animal. It took her nearly a year to find the rest of the
beast. The creature had flippers like a dolphin and teeth like a
crocodile.
Henry Hoste Henley, Lord of the Manor of Colway, bought
the fossil for twenty-three pounds and donated it to William
Bullock's London Museum of Stuffed Animals. Mary and Joseph's
discovery quickly became a popular exhibit. Scholars and others came
from near and far and paid a shilling to see the fossil.
Neither
fame nor fortune came to the Annings. The twenty-three pounds would
feed the Anning family for six months, but the fossil soon resold
for twice as much as the Annings had received. Although Mary
continued looking for, and selling curiosities, the Annings remained
on parish relief.
In 1812, England's new war with the United
States brought even more hardship to the area. Jobs such as
shipbuilding, lace making, and hand weaving vanished. Sailing ships
had become so large, they could not fit into the harbour, and the
shipyards soon went out of business.
During this period, fortunes
were made in textile and mining industries. With more leisure time,
the wealthier middle-class began to flock to seaside resorts. Lyme
Regis with its beautiful sunny bay and mild climate soon became an
inexpensive vacation spot.
Mary and her mother sold curiosities
set out on a round table outside the window of the carpentry shop.
Mary searched the shores early each morning looking for fossils.
Rains seeped through the clay and limestone of the cliffs, and great
chunks of rock slid into the ocean, which uncovered layers of earth,
stone, and fossils.
In 1813, Mary received her first geology book
from Mrs Stock, a woman she ran errands for. Mary began borrowing
and reading everything she could find about the new science of
geology and the even newer science of palaeontology. Mary also
studied modern creatures. She dissected dead squid and cuttlefish in
an attempt to learn how the muscles of ancient sea creatures might
have worked.
Mary had a friendship with three well-to-do sisters,
Mary, Margaret and Elizabeth Philpot. Elizabeth, the youngest, was
nineteen years older than Mary Anning. They all helped each other
learn much about fossilised creatures.
As a teenager, Mary Anning
often guided William Buckland, an Oxford University clergyman who
vacationed in Lyme. In those days it was not unusual to be both a
preacher and a scientist; geology was then seen as a romantic and
spiritual science. This attitude, however, would change as new
geological discoveries raised many questions about the history of
the earth and challenged previous assumptions.
Mary also guided
Henry de la Beche. Mary, William, and Henry scoured the cliffs
looking for fossils on many occasions. Mary found fossils, Henry
drew them, and William wrote about them for other scholars.
After
the French Emperor Napoleon was defeated at Waterloo in 1815, the
economy of Dorset collapsed. The war was over, and it was not
necessary to pay for a large army and navy. The government abolished
income taxes levied on the rich and increased indirect taxation on
food and other necessities, primarily paid by the lower classes.
Despite her success in finding fossils, Mary Anning and her family
continued to face poverty.
Charles Konig purchased the creature
Joseph and Mary had found in 1811, from William Bullock, and placed
it in the British Museum. Charles suggested it looked like a fish
lizard. Putting the Greek words for 'fish' and 'lizard' together, he
suggested the name Ichthyosaurus, meaning 'fish lizard'. Even though
it turned out to be neither a fish nor a lizard, but a swimming
reptile, the name stuck.
Concerned about the Anning's poverty, a
retired lieutenant colonel, Thomas James Birch, auctioned his
collection of fossils at Bullock's London Museum to raise funds for
the family in 1820. The auction attracted many buyers including
Georges Cuvier from Paris. The sale gave the Anning's fossil
business much needed publicity. Four hundred pounds was given to
Molly Anning and - for a short while - the family had no worries
about money.
In May 1821, Mary uncovered two more Ichthyosaur
skeletons, one five feet long and another nearly twenty feet long.
Based on the teeth, scholars determined they were different species.
These finds touched off the very first fossil frenzy.
The Anning's
continued to struggle. Mary regretted having been born a woman and
being deprived of the life and position she might have had as a man.
By 1823, Mary began to receive a little recognition. She sold a
fine ichthyosaur to a group of geologists who donated it to the new
Bristol Institution for the Advancement of Science. Mary's name was
never mentioned as the person who found the specimen. This prompted
George Cumberland, English writer, fossil collector, and amateur
artist, to write to the Bristol newspaper praising the preserving
industry of a young female fossilist, of the name of Hanning… He
had spelled her name the way the local people pronounced it.

Mary stunned the scientific world in December 1823 when she
uncovered a creature nine feet long and six feet wide with a head
less than five inches long. Hearing of Mary's discovery, William
Conybeare, a clergyman and a member of the newly formed Geological
Society of London, described the find and, with the help of de la
Beche, concluded that another large ancient sea creature besides
ichthyosaur must have once lived. They named it Plesiosaurus, which
means 'almost like a lizard'.
The fossil was sold to the Duke of
Buckingham for 110 pounds. Once again, Mary received little praise. Conybeare gave a speech to the Geological Society thanking the Duke
for letting scientists see the fossil. He praised the scientific
public for the discovery, rather than Mary. However, Conybeare did
credit Mary for the discovery when he described the creature to the
Bristol Philosophical and Literary Society.
The New Monthly
Magazine called Mary Anning the well-known fossilist, whose labours
lately have enriched the British Museum as well as the private
collections of many geologists. Finding Plesiosaurus firmly
established Mary's reputation as a first rate fossil hunter.
Mary
continued digging up fossils. She found
'fish-spears', the fin-bones that protected the primitive shark Hybodus. She also discovered four species of ammonites. Mary wrote
to the British Museum in 1824 to ask for a full list of its
collection and taught herself French so she could read Cuvier in his
original language.
As time passed, Mary learned more about the
fossils she collected; her knowledge surpassed that of many
gentlemen fossilists. However, it was always they who formally
studied her specimens, publishing their findings in learned
journals, often without mentioning her name. This would not have
been an issue with Mary during the early years, as she struggled in
relative obscurity. But as she grew intellectually and her
discoveries won her acclaim and celebrity, she naturally became
resentful. It has been claimed that William Buckland who was now
Oxford University's first professor of geology, was a target of her
scorn.
Thomas Allen, a banker and amateur geologist from Edinburgh
met with Mary Anning and purchased a fine specimen of Hybodus she
had uncovered. Allen entered in his journal for June 1824, "the
scientific are entirely indebted to her for the preservation of some
of the finest remains of a former world that are known in Europe."
So confident was she of her skills, he added, "she is perfectly
acquainted with the anatomy of her subjects, and her account of her
disputes with Buckland, whose anatomical science she holds in great
contempt, was quite amusing."
Mary had some recognition for her
intellectual mastery of the anatomy of her subjects from Lady
Harriet Silvester, an English noblewoman. After meeting Mary in
1824, she recorded in her diary, "The extraordinary thing in this
young woman is that she has made herself as thoroughly acquainted
with the science that the moment she finds any bones she knows to
what tribe they belong. It is certainly a wonderful instance of
divine favour - that this poor, ignorant girl should be so blessed,
for by reading and application she has arrived to that degree of
knowledge as to be in the habit of writing and talking with
professors and other clever men on the subject, and they all
acknowledge that she understands more of the science than anyone
else in this kingdom."
In July 1824, the French geologist
Louis-Constant Prévost and the young Scottish lawyer and amateur
geologist Charles Lyell visited the celebrated Mary Anning and
witnessed the discovery of a beautiful ichthyosaurus only two feet
long.
In 1826, Mary used the benefits of her growing fame and
purchased a house on Broad Street just down from the Philpot's.
Moving uphill in Lyme Regis meant climbing in status. The front of
the house was turned into a shop. A little white sign in front read
'Anning's Fossil Depot.'
Hardship hit once again when sixty
English banks went bankrupt during 1825 and 1826. Many of those who
had purchased fossils in the past were affected, and the price of
fossils fell. Mary managed by putting her fossils in shops on
consignment and improving her marketing skills. She concentrated
on excavating smaller fossils as they were much more affordable.
Mary often forced scholars to look at familiar objects in new ways.
She was the first to discover a tiny chamber of purple powder inside
belemnites that looked like dried ink. When ground up and added to
water, Mary discovered she could draw with it. William Buckland was
startled one day to receive a sketch of one ancient creature, an
ichthyosaur, drawn with the ink made from another.
Even some of
Mary's smallest finds revealed secrets of the past. 'Bezoar stones'
shaped like the gallstones of Bezoar goats were frequently found on
the beach. Most were dark gray, two or four inches long, and an inch
or two in diameter. They were tightly twisted and some had black
spots. Having found these inside the skeletons of ichthyosaurs, Mary
was the first to recognise they were fossilised clumps of undigested
food that stayed in the animals intestines when it died, or was
expelled at death. William Buckland named them Coprolites or 'dung
stones'.
Mary's discovery of coprolites led to the understanding
of how fossils were made. If something as soft as undigested food
could be preserved, then some fossils must have been created by the
sudden entombment of animals before even the softest tissue could
decay.
Coprolites were a window to the past. One of William
Buckland's students, John Shute Duncan, who later became the head of
the Ashmolean Museum at Oxford, wrote a poem:
Approach, approach,
ingenuous youth
And learn this fundamental truth
The noble science
of Geology
Is bottomed firmly on Coprology.
In November 1828, Mary
made another significant find, a jawless fish Dapedium politum. In
December of that same year, she uncovered the first flying reptile
ever found in England. William Buckland told the Geological Society
of London this unknown species was the size of a raven, three and a
half feet long with skin-covered wings stretched from its body out
to the long fingers of its forearms. Its enormous head had massive
but lightweight jaws with four big sharp teeth at the front and
smaller equally sharp teeth at the back. Eventually scholars named
this pterosaur Dimorphodon, which means two forms of teeth.
With
the discovery of Ichthyosaurus, Plesiosaurus, and Dimorphodon, Mary
Anning's fossil business was now famous among British scientists and
was becoming well known elsewhere. In 1829, Mary found another
complete plesiosaur and another new species of fish later named
Squaloraja.
More hardship befell the Anning family in 1830. With
revolution in Belgium and France and more bread riots at home, those
who had money were reluctant to spend it. Fossil prices continued to
fall. To raise money for the Annings, Henry de la Beche drew a
picture called An Earlier Dorset. It showed how he imagined
prehistoric life. Along with some reptile dung, he packed in all the
creatures the Annings had found.
In December 1830, Mary made
another great discovery, a plesiosaur with a much larger head and
even more neck bones. It was purchased by William Willoughby.
Richard Owen thanked Willoughby for letting him examine it, but
failed to mention who had found it. He referred to it as 'Hawkins
plesiosaur' because Thomas Hawkins, an eccentric collector, had
proposed a name for it.
In the following years, Mary continued to
find more ichthyosaurs and various fossils. Scholars frequently
overlooked the significance of Mary's finds. Geologists at Cambridge
lost the coprolite Mary had collected with an ichthyosaur skeleton
not realising the importance of this tiny object. The British Museum
somehow misplaced all but the head of Mary and Joseph's first
ichthyosaur, as well as most of a large one Mary found in 1832.
In
1832, the worldwide cholera epidemic reached Lyme. Mary and most of
her friends were spared. The following year, fire swept through
Lyme, but once again, Mary was not hurt.
Mary faced a close call
one day in 1833 when tons of rock fell around her while she was
fossil collecting at the base of the cliffs on the beach. She was
stunned by the loss of her dog Tray, who was by her side at the
time. Later that same year, Mary narrowly escaped death once again
when a run-away cart pinned her against a wall.
Upset by these
close calls, Mary found comfort in the Bible. This was during a time
when many were leaving the church as the discovery of ancient
fossils undermined faith in the book of Genesis as a literal
description of the creation of the world. For some, visiting the
Fossil Depot was upsetting.
In 1834, Mary Anning and Elizabeth
Philpot helped the Swiss palaeontologist Louis Agassiz study fossil
fish. Mary and Elizabeth showed him how to match the backbones with
teeth found in the same layer of the limestone.
In his pioneering
book Studies of Fossil Fish, Agassiz honored both Mary and Elizabeth
by thanking them for their help in unlocking the secrets of
prehistoric fish. Louis Agassiz eventually became one of the most
important scientists of the nineteenth century. By describing and
drawing prehistoric fish, he provided evidence that life on earth
passed through great catastrophes.
Mary Anning's work continued
to have an enormous impact on life in Victorian England. At the
time, it was generally believed the earth was only 6,000 years old,
but Mary's fossils caused scientists to question whether the earth
was actually much older.
Mary was now known internationally. The
British Association for the Advancement of Science and the British
government gave her a 'Civil List Pension' of twenty-five pounds a
year in appreciation for her work. Between this and the fossils she
sold, Mary and her mother finally lived comfortably.
In September
1839, Richard Owen came to Lyme to see Mary Anning. She led Owen,
Buckland, and Conybeare on a geological excursion. Owen was
impressed with the way Mary scrambled over the cliffs. Owen later
described Mary's remarkable find, Plesiosaurus macrocephalus, to the
Geological Society of London; however, he never mentioned her name.
After the death of her mother, Molly, in 1842, Mary found herself
living alone for the first time. Mary tended the now famous Fossil
Depot by herself. In 1844, King Frederick Augustus of Saxony came to
Lyme with his doctor, Carl Gustav Carus, who later helped develop
the idea of species evolution. The King paid Mary fifteen pounds for
a six-foot-long skeleton of a baby ichthyosaur for his natural
history collection in Dresden - and then asked her for her
autograph. In signing her name, Mary also wrote, 'I am well known
throughout the whole of Europe.'
That same year, another fire
swept through Lyme. Once again, Mary and her home were spared.
Mary learned she had breast cancer in 1845. The members of the
Geological Society of London took up a collection for her, and the
new Dorset County Museum elected her their first honorary member.
These gestures reassured her she was not forgotten.
Mary Anning,
the unsung heroine of Lyme, had been the first loss among the
fossilists. She died on March 9, 1847 at the age of forty-seven. Her
body was buried in St. Michael's Parish church of Lyme Regis, within
site and sound of the sea.
The year following her death, her
lifelong friend, Henry De la Beche, concluded his anniversary
address as president of the Geological Society of London with a
short eulogy, later published in the Quarterly Journal of the
Geological Society. He referred to her as one who had not been
'placed among even the easier classes of society, but who had to
earn her daily bread by her labour...' He acknowledged how she
'contributed by her talents and untiring researches…' to the
knowledge of marine reptiles, and other animals, and how her talents
and good conduct had won her many friends.
The obituary was quite
short, but it was remarkable in itself because she was not a member
of the society - the society did not admit women members until 1904.
This was the only time an obituary was ever given for someone who
was not a member. William Gray's portrait of her, painted around
1842, welcomes visitors to the marine reptile gallery.
Mary was
commemorated by her hometown in 1850 with the installation of a
stained-glass window in St. Michael's Parish Church. It depicts the
corporal works of mercy… feeding the hungry, giving drink to the
thirsty, clothing the naked, sheltering the homeless, visiting
prisoners, and visiting the sick. An inscription reads: 'This
window is sacred to the memory of Mary Anning of this parish, who
died 9 March AD 1847 and is erected by the vicar and some members of
the Geological Society of London in commemoration of her usefulness
in furthering the science of geology, as also of her benevolence of
heart and integrity of life.'
In her last years, Mary enjoyed
scientific recognition, financial security, and a deepening
religious faith. Though poor, she was rich in spirit and had formed
friendships with wealthy collectors and geologists. Uneducated, she
had aided in the development of palaeontology. Although she never
left Lyme Regis, she was known everywhere.
More than fifty years
after the death of Mary Anning, Terry Sullivan was inspired to write
the familiar tongue-twister:
She sells sea-shells on the
sea-shore,
The shells she sells are sea-shells, I'm surer
For if she
sells sea-shells on the sea-shore
Then I'm sure she sells sea-shore
shells.
Two hundred years after Mary Anning's birth an
international delegation of geologists, palaeontologists,
historians, fossil collectors, authors, and other interested parties
gathered in Lyme Regis to celebrate her life and times. The event
was hosted by John Fowles, Lyme's celebrated novelist. And what
might she have said if she had witnessed the 1999 meeting held in
her honour? 'At last', John Fowles offered.
Mary Anning lives on.
Not only in memory and in the legacy of the fossils she discovered,
but also in the work of the contemporary collectors of Lyme.
Where are they now?
The Lyme Regis Museum has an exhibit about
Mary and presents lectures on her life each summer.
The skull of
the first ichthyosaur Mary and Joseph discovered can be seen at the
Museum of Natural History in London (previously called the British
Museum). The plesiosaur she found in 1823, her Dimorphodon, and part
of the enormous ichthyosaur she discovered in 1832 can also be seen.
One of her ichthyosaurs is at the Ulster Museum in Belfast,
Northern Ireland, and the ichthyosaur and the plesiosaur Thomas
Wilson bought are displayed at the Academy of Natural Sciences of
Philadelphia though it is not certain which specimens are hers.
One of the best 'stone lilies' Mary ever found, a Pentacrinus
briareus, and a particularly fine Ichthyosaurus communis, are at the
Bath Royal Literary and Scientific Institution.
The National
Museum of Natural History in Paris has a Plesiosaurus dolichodeirus
Mary uncovered.
The ammonite called Oxynoticeras that Mary found
in 1838 is at the Somerset County Museum in Taunton.
Several
fossil specimens collected by Mary can be seen at the Sedgewick
Museum in Cambridge.
All of Mary's fossils in the Lyceum of
Natural History in New York City were lost to fire when the museum
burned to the ground.
Several of her finds were destroyed during
the World War II bombing raids.
Acknowledgments
I would like
to thank the Alberta Palaeontological Society for keeping my mania
in palaeontology alive and the Scott family for their help with
editing.
Bibliography
Goodhue, Thomas W. Curious Bones: Mary
Anning and the Birth of Palaeontology, North Carolina: Morgan
Reynolds, 2002.
McGowan, Chris. The Dragon Seekers: How an
Extraordinary Circle of Fossilists Discovered the Dinosaur and Paved
the Way for Darwin, Cambridge, MA: Perseus, 2001.
Cadbury,
Deborah. Terrible Lizard: The First Dinosaur Hunters and the Birth
of a New Science, New York: Henry Holt, 2001.
Cadbury, Deborah.
The Dinosaur Hunters: A True Story of Scientific Rivalry the
Discovery of the Prehistoric World, Great Britain: Clays Ltd, St.
Ives plc, 2000.
Gould, Stephen Jay, and Rosamund, Wolf Purcell.
Finders Keepers: Eight Collectors, New York: Norton, 1992.
Alic,
Margaret. Hypatia's Heritage: A History of Women in Science from
Antiquity through the Nineteenth Century, Boston: Beacon Press,
1986.
Torrens, Hugh S. 'Mary Anning (1799-1847) of Lyme: The
Greatest Fossilist the World Ever Knew', 'British Journal for the
History of Science 28 (1995): 257-284.'
Websites
A great family day out...


Left: Participants
on various Discovering Fossils and Junior Geo fossil hunting events.
Right: Families handle some real
fossils at the event base.
Join us on an organised fossil hunt!
Discovering Fossils and JuniorGeo have joined forces to provide a
series of exciting prehistoric experiences for families and
individuals of all ages and levels of knowledge. Our events include
an introduction to the geology and fossils, followed by a
group fossil hunt where everyone has an opportunity to find and
collect a variety of fossils. To find out more
CLICK HERE.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement